May 24, 2012 - submitted by Fokke, Switzerland

Q. Dear Oracle,

Like yourself, I love the song What If from X&Y. I don't think they ever played this song live. Do you know why?
I will go to to concert in Zurich this Saturday and obviously hope that you can influence the guys to put this on their playlist :-)

Best regards from a Dutch guy in Switzerland.

The Oracle replies:

It was played during the Twisted Logic tour back in 2005 but it wasn't a permanent fixture on the setlist.
Last December it reappeared, much to my delight, on the European leg of the tour after a lengthy hiatus.